The Meaning We Make: How Neutral Thoughts Become Personal Truth
We are shaped by our thoughts; we become what we think.
I've been thinking a lot about the meaning we assign to thingsβand how, if we strip away all the layers of interpretation, we'd see that all thoughts are, at their core, neutral. It's the meaning we attach to a thought that charges it, and it's that meaning, not the thought itself, that gives rise to our emotional reactions.
Since I can't yet write without a lot of pain (hand surgery), I've been "writing" by voice.
I want to share a lightly edited transcription of how I unpack the meanings I've given specific thoughtsβand how, in doing so, my relationship to those thoughts begins to shift.
So, todayβs piece is a portal into my thought processβthe things I turn over again and again, and how I try to disentangle false beliefs from simple thoughts.
Voice Note: On Meaning and Reaction
I have a lot to do today, and Iβm feeling stressed. But the stress isnβt coming from the tasks themselvesβitβs coming from the meaning Iβm assigning to them. That meaning creates pressure, and that pressure leads me to believe two things:
A) I wonβt get it all done, and
B) I wonβt understand how to do what needs doing.
So Iβm not stressed because I have too much to do. Iβm layering meaning on top of that factβa meaning shaped by life experience, years of conditioning, and everything Iβve been taught to believe about myself as accurate (though that doesnβt mean itβs true).
To understand where this meaning comes from, I need to look back.
I grew up not knowing the name of the dread that ruled me. Ordinary thingsβlike sleeping at a friendβs house or having someone sleep overβwere terrifying. If I couldnβt keep a close eye on my mom, I was convinced one of us would die. No other kid I knew seemed trapped inside a medium of terror they couldnβt escape.
The world I lived in had different rules from the world everyone else inhabited. The danger signals my body sent me were loud and happened constantly throughout each day. I didnβt understand things other people did, like what to do if I got kidnapped or if my mom died. The answer was always the same whenever I askedβdonβt worry, that wonβt happen.
This made my anxiety worse, holding me hostage not to the questions themselves, but to the terror of not knowing.
Within that medium of terror, more meanings took root. The fear from my undiagnosed panic disorder began to organize itself around the idea that I couldnβt understand. School became one of the places where this played out most intensely. Knowing I was supposed to learn and βknowβ what our teacher taught led me to panic during the teaching. My ears felt dense and blocked, my bones vibrated, and the world doubled. I didnβt know this was panic. I thought this was an innate inability to learn, to understand.
Anxiety is a fear of uncertainty, of not knowing what will happen next. Not knowing is a trigger for people with anxiety. If we donβt know what will happen next, we remain afraid.
Over time, this fear became a central layer of my experience. Whenever I was taught something new, the pressure of possibly not understanding became so loud that I couldnβt hear past it.
Teachers and adults misread this anxiety as a fundamental incapacity to learn.
They called me a βslow learner.β
But what I heard was: You are stupid.
I couldnβt ask questions and expose my panicked world because no child wants to be different. I adapted. I disguised. But the internal meaning had already been set:
I am fundamentally wrong.
I am fundamentally incapable of learning.
When my school flagged my poor standardized test scores, they sent me for more tests: hearing tests, vision tests, writing assessments, IQ testsβhundreds of evaluations over ten years.
As a child, I wasnβt given the results. They went to my mom, who didnβt share them.
This validated my fear that there was truly something wrong with me.
There were vague conversations about a βlearning disability.β Because no one knew I had a panic disorder, I internalized all the fear and dread as proof of stupidity itself.
I was stupid.
That belief became foundational.
Even in my 50s, I battle that feeling almost every day.
Which brings me back to this morning:
I feel a familiar dread when I look at the massive list of things I must do. Not because the tasks themselves are monstrous, but because the old meaning gets activated:
Iβm not smart enough to get through this.
But hereβs the crucial adult skill: slowing down, separating the facts from the meaning.
Identifying what meanings weβre unconsciously assigning to neutral facts, and tracing those meanings back to their origin points.
The fact that I have a lot to do today is neutral.
It becomes charged when I infuse it with meaning: I canβt do it. Iβm not capable.
In life, we often apply meanings to things without realizing it.
Itβs the meaning we respond toβnot the facts themselves.
The daily facts of lifeβthe schedules, the obligations, the ordinary chaosβarenβt inherently threatening. The old, accumulated meanings we attach to them stir up so much reaction inside us.
And the work of adulthood is this: To catch ourselves in the act.
To ask: What meaning am I giving to this? And where did that meaning come from?
If any part of this resonates, I hope it offers a small openingβa moment to notice where meaning is being assigned in your life, and where it might be gently questioned.
Until next week, I will remainβ¦

Amanda
P.S. Thank you for reading! This newsletter is my passion and livelihood; it thrives because of readers like you. If you've found solace, wisdom or insight here, please consider upgrading, and if you think a friend or family member could benefit, please feel free to share. Every bit helps, and Iβm deeply grateful for your support. π
Quick note: Nope, Iβm not a therapistβjust someone who spent 25 years with undiagnosed panic disorder and 23 years in therapy. How to Live distills what Iβve learned through lived experience, therapy, and obsessive researchβso you can skip the unnecessary suffering and better understand yourself.
Some links are affiliate links, meaning I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Every bit goes straight back into supporting this newsletter. Thank you!






Upgrade