Past posts live here. Come 👋🏼 at me on FB, IG, Threads & Bluesky.

The Basement Prisoners: How Dorothea Dix Exposed America's Hidden Mental Health Horrors.

In antebellum America, people afflicted with mental illness were stashed away as mortifying secrets hidden in the side pockets of local geography.

If they lacked attics, wealthy families built annexes to their homes, discrete additions with barred windows and soundproofed walls, and hid their afflicted family members from friends and society.

Less fortunate families resorted to crude shelters or basement cages.

All these efforts to hide and forget afflicted loved ones reflected society's shared view that mental illness was not a medical condition that could improve with treatment, but a moral stain on the family line.

The hidden were often neglected and forgotten, mainly by their own families. Their existence was usually unknown to outsiders.

Sadly, while morally corrupt, these were better options than insane asylums, where patients were “treated” in gruesome and barbaric ways.

This was the landscape into which Dorothea Dix, a proper Boston schoolteacher, stepped one bitterly cold March morning in 1841, when she arrived at East Cambridge Jail, where she was to teach a Sunday school class.

Within the context of the Second Great Awakening—a big push for religious revival in 19th-century America—such visits were among the few sanctioned forms of public service available to middle-class women in antebellum America.

An established educator and author of an incredibly popular textbook, Dorothea kept impressive company, hobnobbing with Ralph Waldo Emerson. She was also worldly, having spent a year in Europe, where she was taken in by the politician and reformer William Rathbone and his wife.

That morning, Dorothea likely expected nothing more dramatic than a morning of Bible readings with the inmates. Instead, she found herself descending into the jail's lowest level, a basement, where she discovered several mentally ill women stripped naked in unheated cells, shivering against stone walls.

When she demanded to know why there was no heat, the jailers offered a response that would stay with her for the rest of her life: the insane, they claimed, could not feel cold.

Why were mentally ill women housed with known criminals, and why did those who’d committed no crimes suffer worse treatment than those who had? These were the questions that would drive Dorothea.

Dorothea was no stranger to mental anguish. Born in 1802 in Hampden, Maine, she was the eldest of three and raised by two alcoholics. Her father was a Methodist preacher who was known to be violent, and her mother suffered terribly from depression. All three children were neglected, but as the eldest child, Dorothea was forced to navigate the unstable terrain of adult dysfunction, becoming a caretaker by necessity. In today’s parlance, she had a parentified childhood.

She later wrote in her journal: "The child who knows too early the weight of others' pain carries it forever, like a second skeleton beneath the skin."

That morning in East Cambridge, as she descended into the jail's lower level, the familiar scents of her childhood—tobacco, dampness, and despair—seemed to follow her down the narrow stairs. What she discovered in those underground chambers would haunt her for the rest of her life.

But that one statement, crystallizing centuries of institutional cruelty in a single, ethically violent assertion that “the insane cannot feel cold,” struck Dix with particular force.

During her episodes of what she called her "black times"—periods of depression so severe she’d left America to seek treatment in England—she experienced not just an emotional numbness but also an acute sensitivity to physical discomfort, both typical symptoms of mental illness, although not commonly known at that time.

The jailers' casual cruelty revealed not just ignorance but a deeper pathology in American society: the need to help those whose suffering made the comfortable uncomfortable.

How chilling that this is still true today, almost two centuries later?

At twelve, Dorothea and her siblings left their unstable environment to live with her wealthy grandmother in Boston, where they received a rigorous education, and Dorothea discovered a near obsession with learning and, before long, teaching.

By fourteen, she was not only teaching school but devising the curriculum. She opened her school (the first of several) at age twenty, and wrote a textbook for girls called Conversations on Common Things, published in 1824, which became widely used throughout New England.

Although still a teenager, she developed her educational philosophy, which emphasized both practical knowledge and moral development, reflecting her belief that education could serve as a bulwark against the kind of chaos she’d known in childhood.

Education, she understood, was the way through and the way out.

Like most people deprived of childhood, Dorothea carried her trauma with her, experiencing recurring bouts of depression that would eventually force her to seek treatment in England.

Her history of depression, coupled with her parents’ struggles, triggered something in her during her first visit to the East Cambridge jail. So horrified by what she found, she began visiting jails and almshouses across America, investigating how our country treated its mentally ill, and what she discovered defied even her intimate knowledge of human cruelty.

So she did what anyone obsessed with learning does—she began methodically documenting what she saw.

And what she did with that documentation changed the entire landscape of mental health care in America.

If this gave you something to chew on, the rest will too. Upgrade to learn how Dorothea Dix revolutionized the mental health care system.

Join How to Live