This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Freud and Adler's Friendship Ended Over an Idea. A Book Built on It Sold 3.5 Million Copies.

Do not live to satisfy the expectations of others.

Alfred Adler

In 1902, Sigmund Freud sent an invitation to a young Austrian psychotherapist named Alfred Adler, asking him to come to his house and talk about the mind:

Upon his acceptance, Adler became one of the founding members of “The Wednesday Psychological Society” (later the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society), the room where modern psychology more or less began.

Ten years later, Alfred Adler walked out.

Freud told the story afterward as a betrayal, and history has mostly gone along with him. While Freud is the name everyone knows, Adler built out his psychology based on his disagreements with Freud, and it’s having a moment. Yet, most people living according to Adler’s ideas couldn't tell you where they came from.

Freud's model was built on the inside of a person: the subconscious, the split self, the idea that whatever was wrong with you was buried somewhere underneath and had to be dug up. The internal world captivated Freud, almost to the exclusion of external elements.

Adler, however, believed people were shaped by the web around them, family, friendship, work, the whole social fabric a person never actually exists apart from. He believed that everyone shared the need to belong and that personal problems were, in fact, interpersonal. He thought Freud overemphasized sex to explain human behavior.

Instead of looking at a person in isolation to understand their behavior, Adler saw people through their family system, friendships, societal roles, and culture. To understand a human being involved, consider the internal and external worlds together.

Adlerian psychology (also known as “Individual Psychology”) is the psychology of growth, where people strive to overcome difficulties and actually change their lives. Though his name may not be as well known as Freud and Carl Jung, Adler’s original ideas are embedded in modern practice.

Alfred Adler | Getty Images | Heritage Images

Two Japanese psychotherapists, Ichiro Kishimi and Fumitake Koga, took Adler's psychology and turned it into a dialogue between a philosopher and a frustrated young student (which takes some getting used to) published as The Courage to Be Disliked: The Japanese Phenomenon That Shows You How to Change Your Life and Achieve Real Happiness. It came out in Japan in 2013 and it reveals how to apply Adlerian Individual psychology to contemporary life.

The english edition published in 2018, and has since sold over 13 million copies worldwide, almost outselling my own book, Little Panic: Dispatches from an anxious life.

Like many books, it became famous on TikTok.

Buried in that dialogue is a single question the philosopher keeps returning the student to, one that isn't a direct quote from Adler so much as Kishimi and Koga's distillation of a concept Adler called the separation of tasks.

What that question opens up is either the most freeing idea to come out of pop psychology's raid on Adler, or the most convenient excuse anyone has built for not caring what people think of you.

Here’s the question:

Below, I reveal the single most freeing question a person can ask, and unpack the reasons how it can offer clarity and put an end to the most insidious feature of some people’s lives: people pleasing.

Paid subscribers get this essay plus 200+ others in the archive. Upgrade here.

logo

Annual Memberships

An inquiry into what it’s like to be a person, and what we make of what happens to us.

Subscribe to continue reading

What's included:

  • Every new essay, the moment it’s published
  • Full access to the complete archive — 150+ pieces and counting
  • Occasional bonus essays and experiments-in-progress shared exclusively with members
  • Invitations to seasonal, in-person gatherings
  • A direct line to me (annual members): personal replies and tailored recommendations
  • 15% off all workshops and live events

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Keep Reading