You’re reading How to Live, a weekly examination of the forces shaping your thoughts, choices, and patterns you can’t escape. Most of what drives us operates below awareness; this newsletter names it.
Paid subscribers make this work possible. They also get what free readers don’t: psychological insight that doesn’t just explain your life, it makes it conscious, like something you already knew but couldn’t name. Plus four years of archives, twice-yearly essays drawn from what readers are thinking about, and a monthly vote on the next topic. $6/month or $67/year
The Illusion of Mastery: Why We Mistake Control for Safety
As an adult, I’ve always been driven to identify the root cause of every problem (except math).
Perhaps it’s because I discovered decades ago that being able to name a difficult or problematic feeling or experience releases its grip. At least, that’s the effect it has on me. Where it’s tough is when I’m trying to identify the roots of a problem from which I don’t suffer.

I am not a micro or macro manager, and I don’t feel compelled to control how other people do things, I only have the compulsion to control how I do things. In my apartment, for example, there is not one right way to do the dishes or load the dishwasher (confession: I don't have a dishwasher, but you feel me). There is no one right to be; there is no one right way to clean.
I am not someone who believes my way is the best—or worst—way. I am a go-with-the-flow type of person (sometimes to my own detriment) and follow the road that feels right to me, but may not be right for someone else.
So, naturally, people who need to control their environment, and the people who enter that environment, are curious creatures to me. But the closer we become, the more their inflexibility impacts me. My innate character can wind up feeling strangled.
While I understand that people’s issues are not personal—as in, they are not about me—the expression of certain problematic behaviors that are directed at me conjure the very feelings I believe the controlling person is trying hard not to feel.
When a person doesn’t identify or deal with the origin point of their problems because it’s uncomfortable and scary, they tend to engage in behavior that inadvertently consigns someone else the emotion they are afraid to feel, or they accidentally re-create the scenario that most terrifies them.

Hypnose produite par un diapason - 1899 KAROLY LAUFENAUER©DOMAINE PUBLIC
For instance:
Imagine a person who fears being forgotten, and who has not faced the roots of their fear. They might create scenarios that require others to come to their aid, as a maladaptive way to get their need to be remembered met, and to prove to themselves they are worthy of being cared for and loved.
But when you haven’t dealt with the fear of being forgotten, those demands are bottomless. And so another scenario is created and then another. This can become a cycle of problematic behavior, where the person who needs soothing is overly reliant on others to do for them what they cannot do for themselves.
Over time, this leads to resentment—those who are overly relied upon feel taken for granted, erased, or not seen. Because they are not seen, they are being used.

Heidi Rosin
The day will inevitably arrive where the overly-relied-upon person wants out, but they are stuck because the person who is being too dependent on them is the very person afraid of being forgotten.
What to do?
Below, I walk you through what controlling behavior is masking, what to look for, and how to understand what you’re seeing.
Once you understand a harmful behavior, it’s often easier to do something about it, or simply walk way.
Paid subscribers get this essay plus 200+ others in the archive. Upgrade here.
You're reading How to Live
A weekly examination of the unconscious logic behind our attachments, defenses, distortions, and recurring dilemmas.
Unlock Every EssayAs a member, you’ll gain access to:
- Every new essay, the moment it’s published
- Full access to the complete archive — 150+ pieces and counting
- Occasional bonus essays and experiments-in-progress shared exclusively with members
- Invitations to seasonal, in-person gatherings
- A direct line to me (annual members): personal replies and tailored recommendations
- 15% off all workshops and live events
